Located in Islamorada, Amara Cay Resort is by the ocean, minutes from Bud n' Mary's Dive Center, and close to Hurricane Monument. This beach hotel is within close proximity of Lignumvitae Key Botanical State Park and History of Diving Museum.
Room
Amenities Relax on the private beach or enjoy other recreational amenities such as an outdoor pool and a fitness center. Additional features at this hotel include wireless Internet access (surcharge), gift shops/newsstands, and wedding services. Guests can get around on the complimentary shuttle, which operates within 4.00 mi.
Room STANDARD
STANDARD
STANDARD
SUITE QUEEN SIZE BED
QUEEN SIZE BED
QUEEN SIZE BED
QUADRUPLE WITH SHARED BATHROOM
WITH SHARED BATHROOM
WITH SHARED BATHROOM
Double or Twin PARTIAL SEA VIEW
PARTIAL SEA VIEW
PARTIAL SEA VIEW
SUITE ONE BEDROOM WITH VIEWS
ONE BEDROOM WITH VIEWS
ONE BEDROOM WITH VIEWS
SUITE SEA VIEW
SEA VIEW
SEA VIEW
SUITE TWO DOUBLE BEDS
TWO DOUBLE BEDS
TWO DOUBLE BEDS
DOUBLE OCEAN FRONT
OCEAN FRONT
OCEAN FRONT
SUITE OCEAN FRONT KING BED
OCEAN FRONT KING BED
OCEAN FRONT KING BED
SUITE TWO QUEEN BEDS
TWO QUEEN BEDS
TWO QUEEN BEDS
SUITE KING SIZE BED
KING SIZE BED
KING SIZE BED
DOUBLE OCEAN FRONT
OCEAN FRONT
OCEAN FRONT
Room RUN OF HOUSE
RUN OF HOUSE
RUN OF HOUSE
DOUBLE OCEAN FRONT KING BED
OCEAN FRONT KING BED
OCEAN FRONT KING BED
DOUBLE Accessible KING SIZE BED
Accessible KING SIZE BED
Accessible KING SIZE BED
Room WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
QUADRUPLE PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW
PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW
PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW
Room SEA FRONT
SEA FRONT
SEA FRONT
DOUBLE WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
Double or Twin INNER
INNER
INNER
DOUBLE TWO DOUBLE BEDS
TWO DOUBLE BEDS
TWO DOUBLE BEDS
DOUBLE WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
SINGLE OCEAN FRONT
OCEAN FRONT
OCEAN FRONT
Double or Twin OCEAN FRONT KING BED
OCEAN FRONT KING BED
OCEAN FRONT KING BED
DOUBLE KING SIZE BED
KING SIZE BED
KING SIZE BED
Double or Twin SEA VIEW
SEA VIEW
SEA VIEW
Double or Twin OCEAN FRONT
OCEAN FRONT
OCEAN FRONT
DOUBLE TWO QUEEN BEDS
TWO QUEEN BEDS
TWO QUEEN BEDS
Room Accessible
Accessible
Accessible
SUITE ONE BEDROOM
ONE BEDROOM
ONE BEDROOM
Double or Twin Accessible WITH VIEWS
Accessible WITH VIEWS
Accessible WITH VIEWS
DOUBLE WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
STUDIO STANDARD
STANDARD
STANDARD
Bed in dormitory INNER
INNER
INNER
Room OCEAN FRONT
OCEAN FRONT
OCEAN FRONT
SUITE PREMIUM
PREMIUM
PREMIUM
QUADRUPLE STANDARD
STANDARD
STANDARD
SINGLE INNER
INNER
INNER
QUADRUPLE SEA VIEW
SEA VIEW
SEA VIEW
DOUBLE WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
DOUBLE TWO QUEEN BEDS
TWO QUEEN BEDS
TWO QUEEN BEDS
SUITE WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
DOUBLE KING SIZE BED
KING SIZE BED
KING SIZE BED
SUITE ONE BED
ONE BED
ONE BED
QUADRUPLE OCEAN FRONT
OCEAN FRONT
OCEAN FRONT
SUITE WITH DOUBLE BED
WITH DOUBLE BED
WITH DOUBLE BED
SINGLE SEA VIEW
SEA VIEW
SEA VIEW
Room PARTIAL SEA VIEW
PARTIAL SEA VIEW
PARTIAL SEA VIEW
QUADRUPLE QUEEN SIZE BED
QUEEN SIZE BED
QUEEN SIZE BED
SUITE TWO QUEEN BEDS ONE BEDROOM
TWO QUEEN BEDS ONE BEDROOM
TWO QUEEN BEDS ONE BEDROOM
QUADRUPLE WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
Bed in dormitory STANDARD
STANDARD
STANDARD
SUITE WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
SUITE TWO QUEEN BEDS PREMIUM
TWO QUEEN BEDS PREMIUM
TWO QUEEN BEDS PREMIUM
DOUBLE Accessible WITH VIEWS
Accessible WITH VIEWS
Accessible WITH VIEWS
DOUBLE SEA VIEW KING BED
SEA VIEW KING BED
SEA VIEW KING BED
Double or Twin Accessible KING SIZE BED
Accessible KING SIZE BED
Accessible KING SIZE BED
Double or Twin Accessible
Accessible
Accessible
SINGLE Accessible
Accessible
Accessible
QUADRUPLE INNER
INNER
INNER
DOUBLE WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
Double or Twin KING SIZE BED
KING SIZE BED
KING SIZE BED
DOUBLE SINGLE USE STANDARD
STANDARD
STANDARD
Room SIDE SEA VIEW
SIDE SEA VIEW
SIDE SEA VIEW
SUITE OCEAN FRONT TWO DOUBLE BEDS
OCEAN FRONT TWO DOUBLE BEDS
OCEAN FRONT TWO DOUBLE BEDS
Room OCEAN FRONT KING BED
OCEAN FRONT KING BED
OCEAN FRONT KING BED
SUITE PREMIUM SEA VIEW
PREMIUM SEA VIEW
PREMIUM SEA VIEW
STUDIO KING SIZE BED
KING SIZE BED
KING SIZE BED
SUITE TWO QUEEN BEDS WITH VIEWS
TWO QUEEN BEDS WITH VIEWS
TWO QUEEN BEDS WITH VIEWS
Room SEA VIEW
SEA VIEW
SEA VIEW
DOUBLE PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW
PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW
PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW
DOUBLE PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW QUEEN BED
PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW QUEEN BED
PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW QUEEN BED
DOUBLE SEA FRONT
SEA FRONT
SEA FRONT
SUITE OCEAN FRONT ONE BEDROOM
OCEAN FRONT ONE BEDROOM
OCEAN FRONT ONE BEDROOM
QUADRUPLE SEA FRONT
SEA FRONT
SEA FRONT
DOUBLE KING SIZE BED
KING SIZE BED
KING SIZE BED
SUITE STANDARD
STANDARD
STANDARD
DOUBLE SEA VIEW
SEA VIEW
SEA VIEW
DOUBLE PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW
PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW
PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW
DOUBLE Accessible
Accessible
Accessible
Room INNER
INNER
INNER
SUITE PREMIUM QUEEN BED
PREMIUM QUEEN BED
PREMIUM QUEEN BED
Double or Twin PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW KING BED
PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW KING BED
PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW KING BED
DOUBLE QUEEN SIZE BED
QUEEN SIZE BED
QUEEN SIZE BED
DOUBLE OCEAN FRONT
OCEAN FRONT
OCEAN FRONT
STUDIO WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
QUADRUPLE PARTIAL SEA VIEW
PARTIAL SEA VIEW
PARTIAL SEA VIEW
SUITE TWO DOUBLE BEDS WITH VIEWS
TWO DOUBLE BEDS WITH VIEWS
TWO DOUBLE BEDS WITH VIEWS
SUITE WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
SUITE OCEAN FRONT
OCEAN FRONT
OCEAN FRONT
DOUBLE STANDARD
STANDARD
STANDARD
DOUBLE OCEAN FRONT
OCEAN FRONT
OCEAN FRONT
SUITE SEA FRONT
SEA FRONT
SEA FRONT
DOUBLE PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW KING BED
PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW KING BED
PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW KING BED
DOUBLE PARTIAL SEA VIEW
PARTIAL SEA VIEW
PARTIAL SEA VIEW
DOUBLE WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
DOUBLE KING SIZE BED
KING SIZE BED
KING SIZE BED
Room TWO BEDS
TWO BEDS
TWO BEDS
SUITE TWO DOUBLE BEDS PREMIUM
TWO DOUBLE BEDS PREMIUM
TWO DOUBLE BEDS PREMIUM
QUADRUPLE PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW QUEEN BED
PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW QUEEN BED
PARTIAL OCEAN VIEW QUEEN BED
SUITE ONE BEDROOM
ONE BEDROOM
ONE BEDROOM
STUDIO WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
SUITE KING BED ONE BEDROOM
KING BED ONE BEDROOM
KING BED ONE BEDROOM
Double or Twin STANDARD
STANDARD
STANDARD
SUITE PREMIUM ONE BEDROOM
PREMIUM ONE BEDROOM
PREMIUM ONE BEDROOM
Bed in dormitory PARTIAL SEA VIEW
PARTIAL SEA VIEW
PARTIAL SEA VIEW
SUITE PREMIUM OCEAN FRONT
PREMIUM OCEAN FRONT
PREMIUM OCEAN FRONT
Room RUN OF HOUSE
RUN OF HOUSE
RUN OF HOUSE
Double or Twin WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
WITH VIEWS
dining
Dining Satisfy your appetite at one of the hotel's 2 restaurants. Relax with a refreshing drink from a poolside bar or one of the 2 bars/lounges. Breakfast is available daily for a fee.
Pricing
Select a date on the calendar to view details about the itinerary. If a price is not displayed on any date, click CHECK RATES for the day your want to depart to load prices for your required dates
At Travel Concierge, we take pride in being able to negotiate the best holiday deals at Amara Cay Resort. Our calendar search tool allows you to view holiday prices at Amara Cay Resort for different days within each month so that you can find the cheapest price at Amara Cay Resort for your requirements. Our calendar search displays Amara Cay Resort holiday prices upto 11 months in advance. If you want to book Amara Cay Resort further in advance, we can book Islamorada holidays at Amara Cay Resort in 2027 and 2028. For all Islamorada 2027 holidays and Islamorada 2028 holidays you will have to call us for pricing.
At Travel Concierge, we take pride in being able to negotiate the best holiday deals at Amara Cay Resort. Use the search form below to find holiday prices at Amara Cay Resort. Our Amara Cay Resort holiday search will provide prices up to 11 months in advance of departure. We can book Islamorada holidays at Amara Cay Resort in 2027 and 2028. For all Amara Cay Resort 2027 holidays and Amara Cay Resort 2028 holidays you will have to call us for pricing.
Location
Rooms Make yourself at home in one of the 110 air-conditioned rooms featuring flat-screen televisions. Wireless Internet access (surcharge) is available to keep you connected. Private bathrooms with bathtubs or showers feature complimentary toiletries and hair dryers. Conveniences include safes and desks, as well as phones with free local calls.
Array
(
[TripAdvisorCache] => Array
(
[id] => 16154
[hotel_id] => 76603
[tripadvisor_id] => 120323
[total_reviews] => 2289
[reviews_rating] => 4
[latitude] => 24.900210
[longitude] => -80.655430
[created] => 2019-06-23 20:47:05
[updated] => 2026-10-11 16:24:58
[subratings] => [{"rating_image_url":"https:\/\/static.tacdn.com\/img2\/ratings\/traveler\/ss4.5.svg","name":"rate_location","value":"4.6","localized_name":"Location"},{"rating_image_url":"https:\/\/static.tacdn.com\/img2\/ratings\/traveler\/ss4.0.svg","name":"rate_sleep","value":"4.2","localized_name":"Sleep Quality"},{"rating_image_url":"https:\/\/static.tacdn.com\/img2\/ratings\/traveler\/ss4.0.svg","name":"rate_room","value":"4.2","localized_name":"Rooms"},{"rating_image_url":"https:\/\/static.tacdn.com\/img2\/ratings\/traveler\/ss4.0.svg","name":"rate_service","value":"4.2","localized_name":"Service"},{"rating_image_url":"https:\/\/static.tacdn.com\/img2\/ratings\/traveler\/ss4.0.svg","name":"rate_value","value":"3.9","localized_name":"Value"},{"rating_image_url":"https:\/\/static.tacdn.com\/img2\/ratings\/traveler\/ss4.5.svg","name":"rate_cleanliness","value":"4.3","localized_name":"Cleanliness"}]
[reviews] => [{"id":"1079527877","lang":"en","location_id":"120323","published_date":"2026-09-27T03:30:54-0400","rating":4,"helpful_votes":"0","rating_image_url":"https:\/\/www.tripadvisor.com\/img\/cdsi\/img2\/ratings\/traveler\/s4.0-24002-5.svg","url":"https:\/\/www.tripadvisor.com\/ShowUserReviews-g34346-d120323-r1079527877-Amara_Cay_Resort-Islamorada_Florida_Keys_Florida.html?m=24002#review1079527877","trip_type":null,"travel_date":"2026-09","text":"We have been staying here for 5 years, and every year we\u2019ve had a wonderful experience. The resort is beautiful, well-maintained, and has always been a place we look forward to returning...","user":{"username":"Faith C","user_location":{"name":null,"id":null}},"title":"5 Years of Wonderful Stays, but Shuttle Service Needs Improvement","is_machine_translated":false},{"id":"1079198320","lang":"en","location_id":"120323","published_date":"2026-09-24T14:19:57-0400","rating":5,"helpful_votes":"0","rating_image_url":"https:\/\/www.tripadvisor.com\/img\/cdsi\/img2\/ratings\/traveler\/s5.0-24002-5.svg","url":"https:\/\/www.tripadvisor.com\/ShowUserReviews-g34346-d120323-r1079198320-Amara_Cay_Resort-Islamorada_Florida_Keys_Florida.html?m=24002#review1079198320","trip_type":null,"travel_date":"2026-09","text":"What a wonderful resort, Melvin down at the boat ramp was so helpful and hooked us up with whatever we needed as far as Watersports go.\n\nDefinitely recommend this place.","user":{"username":"Chris W","user_location":{"name":null,"id":null}},"title":"Melvin was the man.","is_machine_translated":false},{"id":"1078482284","lang":"en","location_id":"120323","published_date":"2026-09-19T13:45:11-0400","rating":5,"helpful_votes":"0","rating_image_url":"https:\/\/www.tripadvisor.com\/img\/cdsi\/img2\/ratings\/traveler\/s5.0-24002-5.svg","url":"https:\/\/www.tripadvisor.com\/ShowUserReviews-g34346-d120323-r1078482284-Amara_Cay_Resort-Islamorada_Florida_Keys_Florida.html?m=24002#review1078482284","trip_type":null,"travel_date":"2026-09","text":"\u2b50\u2b50\u2b50\u2b50\u2b50 THE STAFF DESERVES TO BE RECOGNIZED \u2014 ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE EXPERIENCE!\n\nI truly cannot say enough wonderful things about this hotel and, most importantly, the people who work here. From the...","user":{"username":"aezia s","user_location":{"name":null,"id":null}},"title":"10\/10 RECOMMEND -ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE EXPERIENCE","is_machine_translated":false}]
[write_review] => https://www.tripadvisor.com/UserReview-g34346-d120323-Amara_Cay_Resort-Islamorada_Florida_Keys_Florida.html?m=24002
[url] => https://www.tripadvisor.com/Hotel_Review-g34346-d120323-Reviews-Amara_Cay_Resort-Islamorada_Florida_Keys_Florida.html?m=24002
)
[rating] => 4
[num_reviews] => 2289
[write_review] => https://www.tripadvisor.com/UserReview-g34346-d120323-Amara_Cay_Resort-Islamorada_Florida_Keys_Florida.html?m=24002
[url] => https://www.tripadvisor.com/Hotel_Review-g34346-d120323-Reviews-Amara_Cay_Resort-Islamorada_Florida_Keys_Florida.html?m=24002
[reviews] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[id] => 1079527877
[lang] => en
[location_id] => 120323
[published_date] => 2026-09-27T03:30:54-0400
[rating] => 4
[helpful_votes] => 0
[rating_image_url] => https://www.tripadvisor.com/img/cdsi/img2/ratings/traveler/s4.0-24002-5.svg
[url] => https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g34346-d120323-r1079527877-Amara_Cay_Resort-Islamorada_Florida_Keys_Florida.html?m=24002#review1079527877
[trip_type] =>
[travel_date] => 2026-09
[text] => We have been staying here for 5 years, and every year we’ve had a wonderful experience. The resort is beautiful, well-maintained, and has always been a place we look forward to returning...
[user] => Array
(
[username] => Faith C
[user_location] => Array
(
[name] =>
[id] =>
)
)
[title] => 5 Years of Wonderful Stays, but Shuttle Service Needs Improvement
[is_machine_translated] =>
)
[1] => Array
(
[id] => 1079198320
[lang] => en
[location_id] => 120323
[published_date] => 2026-09-24T14:19:57-0400
[rating] => 5
[helpful_votes] => 0
[rating_image_url] => https://www.tripadvisor.com/img/cdsi/img2/ratings/traveler/s5.0-24002-5.svg
[url] => https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g34346-d120323-r1079198320-Amara_Cay_Resort-Islamorada_Florida_Keys_Florida.html?m=24002#review1079198320
[trip_type] =>
[travel_date] => 2026-09
[text] => What a wonderful resort, Melvin down at the boat ramp was so helpful and hooked us up with whatever we needed as far as Watersports go.
Definitely recommend this place.
[user] => Array
(
[username] => Chris W
[user_location] => Array
(
[name] =>
[id] =>
)
)
[title] => Melvin was the man.
[is_machine_translated] =>
)
[2] => Array
(
[id] => 1078482284
[lang] => en
[location_id] => 120323
[published_date] => 2026-09-19T13:45:11-0400
[rating] => 5
[helpful_votes] => 0
[rating_image_url] => https://www.tripadvisor.com/img/cdsi/img2/ratings/traveler/s5.0-24002-5.svg
[url] => https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g34346-d120323-r1078482284-Amara_Cay_Resort-Islamorada_Florida_Keys_Florida.html?m=24002#review1078482284
[trip_type] =>
[travel_date] => 2026-09
[text] => ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ THE STAFF DESERVES TO BE RECOGNIZED — ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE EXPERIENCE!
I truly cannot say enough wonderful things about this hotel and, most importantly, the people who work here. From the...
[user] => Array
(
[username] => aezia s
[user_location] => Array
(
[name] =>
[id] =>
)
)
[title] => 10/10 RECOMMEND -ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE EXPERIENCE
[is_machine_translated] =>
)
)
[subratings] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[rating_image_url] => https://static.tacdn.com/img2/ratings/traveler/ss4.5.svg
[name] => rate_location
[value] => 4.6
[localized_name] => Location
)
[1] => Array
(
[rating_image_url] => https://static.tacdn.com/img2/ratings/traveler/ss4.0.svg
[name] => rate_sleep
[value] => 4.2
[localized_name] => Sleep Quality
)
[2] => Array
(
[rating_image_url] => https://static.tacdn.com/img2/ratings/traveler/ss4.0.svg
[name] => rate_room
[value] => 4.2
[localized_name] => Rooms
)
[3] => Array
(
[rating_image_url] => https://static.tacdn.com/img2/ratings/traveler/ss4.0.svg
[name] => rate_service
[value] => 4.2
[localized_name] => Service
)
[4] => Array
(
[rating_image_url] => https://static.tacdn.com/img2/ratings/traveler/ss4.0.svg
[name] => rate_value
[value] => 3.9
[localized_name] => Value
)
[5] => Array
(
[rating_image_url] => https://static.tacdn.com/img2/ratings/traveler/ss4.5.svg
[name] => rate_cleanliness
[value] => 4.3
[localized_name] => Cleanliness
)
)
)
Reviews
If you are planning a Islamorada holiday at Amara Cay Resort why not check reviews from other travellers who have recently returned from their holiday in Islamorada. Find hints and tips from real travellers who have experienced a Amara Cay Resort holiday to ensure that your holiday in Amara Cay Resort, Islamorada is as fulfilling as you want it to be. Many of the staff at Travel Concierge have visited Islamorada and will be able to give first hand information about Amara Cay Resort. Call us now and get ideas and recommendations from our team of Islamorada experts.
Rating
2289 Reviews
Average ratings
TripAdvisor Traveller reviews
Faith C
5 Years of Wonderful Stays, but Shuttle Service Needs Improvement
We have been staying here for 5 years, and every year we’ve had a wonderful experience. The resort is beautiful, well-maintained, and has always been a place we look forward to returning...
Chris W
Melvin was the man.
What a wonderful resort, Melvin down at the boat ramp was so helpful and hooked us up with whatever we needed as far as Watersports go. Definitely recommend this place.
aezia s
10/10 RECOMMEND -ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE EXPERIENCE
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ THE STAFF DESERVES TO BE RECOGNIZED — ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE EXPERIENCE! I truly cannot say enough wonderful things about this hotel and, most importantly, the people who work here. From the...
